If you only pay attention to mainstream media, you might recall advocates for small business sounding like a broken record, constantly repeating the refrain of reducing regulatory burdens. But when New York City’s Small Business First initiative sought public comments last year from small businesses and the public on small business needs and priorities, only 17 percent pointed to reducing regulations.
The rest pointed to more clarity, more support services, and more equity with regard to who can most easily access those support services to navigate the city’s 6,000-plus rules and regulations, and 250ish business-related licenses.
“That’s what we hear from the independent businesses that we work with,” says Stacy Mitchell, co-director of the Institute for Local Self-Reliance, based in Minneapolis, Minnesota. “Many small businesses believe that having a well-run city that looks after the well-being of communities is part of creating an environment where they can be successful. They very much believe in the purposes of rules and regulations, it’s just that they’re often implemented in ways that are overly complex or not well-attuned to the needs and challenges of small business owners.”
So it makes sense that the Small Business First initiative is focusing this year on consolidating touch points and streamlining interactions between the city and its more than 200,000 small businesses. It’s the beginning of a $27 million investment by the city that will run through fiscal year 2019.
“Small Business First is about changing the way the City of New York interacts with small business owners,” Mayor Bill de Blasio said in a statement earlier this year. “This is a concerted effort across the administration to ensure our small business owners have the resources and support they need to flourish.”
“Small Business First is a critical step for our city to build a more diverse and inclusive economy,” says Mindy Tarlow, director of the Mayor’s Office of Operations.
When New York City’s Small Business First initiative sought input from small businesses about their needs and priorities, only 17 percent pointed to reducing regulations. (Credit: New York City’s Small Business First)
Up to 15 city agencies may be involved in the process of starting and running a business. There is currently no central location from which point small business owners or potential small business owners can access all of them. It’s not hard to imagine how this can be an issue for those in the outer boroughs of the Bronx, Queens, Brooklyn or Staten Island, farther from the city’s main government offices in Manhattan. The same could be said for recent immigrants; some are from countries that already have one-stop shops for registering a business.
Currently, many useful services remain scattered across a hodgepodge of citywide websites.
The city technically has a consolidated online portal for starting a business, as well as checking the status of various business permits. Building on that, Small Business First proposes to create the ability for small businesses to have an account on the platform, which would allow them to access records of inspections and initiate transactions without having to constantly fill out new forms (even online forms). Changes in laws and regulations affecting specific business types could generate emails or notifications directly to business owners with an account.
Over at the NYC Business Express website, you can already create an account in order to pay violations, search city records, and get answers to questions about city rules and regulations.
New York City’s Department of Consumer Affairs has its inspection checklists posted online, and occasionally advertises their availability in various places, including on public transportation.
The New York City Business Accelerator office provides a range of free services to small businesses in food and beverage, industrial and retail, including pre-inspection consultations for businesses that are soon to open.
Then there’s New York City Business Solutions, a set of free services offered by the NYC Department of Small Business Services, including financing assistance, legal advice, advice on city contracting, recruiting advice, or help with permits or licenses.
It’s not immediately clear which website is best for any given small business, or how much overlap there is between these existing websites. Even with all of these, if a small business owner is looking to conduct all of his city government business online, there are potentially even more online portals to go through for things like paying taxes or reporting issues with sidewalks, streetlights or other infrastructure.
Since releasing the study in February, there hasn’t been much news from the de Blasio administration about Small Business First. In May, Small Business Services announced a partnership with the Mayor’s Office of Data Analytics (MODA), to send trained client managers to neighborhoods across the five boroughs to provide businesses owners with targeted education based on data showing the specific business needs in a given neighborhood — including top violations, areas of non-compliance, new business growth data, 311 complaints and more. They started with 100 targeted businesses in a high-violation area in the Bronx.
In addition, the de Blasio administration has reduced fines assessed to small businesses by half over the past year, while also cutting violations issued by a third. Maybe it was the summer malaise, maybe it was the Mayor’s much publicized fight with Uber, but there wasn’t much of a fuss raised over that seemingly important bit of progress.
“On the one hand it certainly seems that Mayor de Blasio views small business as part of a progressive economic agenda,” Mitchell says, citing procurement reforms directing more city contracting go to local small businesses as well as minority- and women-owned businesses. “On the other hand, when you look at what’s happening with rising commercial rent and some of the other challenges facing small businesses in New York City, it’s going to take a much more aggressive approach than we’ve seen so far.”
The Equity Factor is made possible with the support of the Surdna Foundation.
Oscar is editor of Next City. Before that, he was a contributing writer and Equitable Cities Fellow for Next City. Since 2011, Oscar has covered community development finance, community banking, impact investing, equitable and inclusive economies, affordable housing, fair housing and more for media outlets such as Shelterforce, B Magazine, Impact Alpha, and Fast Company.